Notenvergabe für "The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway"

[Jan]

Mein ultimatives Lieblingsalbum! Und hier fällt mir die Benotung wirklich schwer, weil es ja an sich ein GESAMTWERK ist... trotzdem:

1.The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (10)
2.Fly On A Windshield (10)
3.Broadway Melody Of 1974 (10)
4.Cuckoo Cocoon (10)
5.In The Cage (10)
6.The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging (8)
7.Back In N.Y.C. (10)
8.Hairless Heart (10)
9.Counting Out Time (8)
10.Carpet Crawlers (10)
11.The Chamber Of 32 Doors (9)
12.Lilywhite Lilith (10)
13.The Waiting Room (10)
14.Anyway (10)
15.Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist (7)
16.The Lamia (10)
17.Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats (10)
18.The Colony Of Slippermen (10)
19.Ravine (9)
20.The Light Dies Down On Broadway (10)
21.Riding The Scree (10)
22.In The Rapids (10)
23.It (8)

Insgesamt 9,52 (okay, habe bei zwei Songs noch extra einen draufgeschlagen, damit es passt ) und damit aufgerundet 10 Punkte!

[genesis]

Eigentlich 9, aber wegen Kultstatus und dem fantastischen Musicalbox Konzert wird auf 10 aufgerundet!

Genesis

[Christian]

1.The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (9)
2.Fly On A Windshield (10)
3.Broadway Melody Of 1974 (10)
4.Cuckoo Cocoon (9)
5.In The Cage (10)
6.The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging (8)
7.Back In N.Y.C. (9)
8.Hairless Heart (10)
9.Counting Out Time (9)
10.Carpet Crawlers (10)
11.The Chamber Of 32 Doors (9)
12.Lilywhite Lilith (10)
13.The Waiting Room (10)
14.Anyway (10)
15.Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist (7)
16.The Lamia (10)
17.Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats (9)
18.The Colony Of Slippermen (10)
19.Ravine (8)
20.The Light Dies Down On Broadway (10)
21.Riding The Scree (8)
22.In The Rapids (8)
23.It (10)


jo - 9 ne?

[C~H]

The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (8)
Fly On A Windshield (10)
Broadway Melody Of 1974 (10)
Cuckoo Cocoon (8)
In The Cage (10)
The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging (8)
Back In N.Y.C. (7)
Hairless Heart (10)
Counting Out Time (4)
Carpet Crawlers (7)
The Chamber Of 32 Doors (8)
Lilywhite Lilith (9)
The Waiting Room (10)
Anyway (10)
Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist (9)
The Lamia (10)
Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats (9)
The Colony Of Slippermen (10)
Ravine (9)
The Light Dies Down On Broadway (8)
Riding The Scree (8)
In The Rapids (8)
It (4)

Gesamt: 8 Punkte

[Jack Sparrow]

schwer schwer schwer

the lamb = 9
windshield = 8
broadway melody = 5
cocoon = 6
cage = 10
parade = 6
nyc = 8
heart = 8
counting = 6
crawlers = 9
chamber = 8

lilith = 8
waiting room = 9
anyway = 7
anaesthetist = 6
lamia = 9
silent sorrow = 7
slippermen = 10
ravine = 7
light dies = 8
scree = 6
rapids = 6
it = 9

7,6 bedeutet 8 punkte für's lamm...durchwachsen aber gesamt - stark!

[C~H]

Vielleicht sollte erwähnt werden, dass "Broadway Melody" bereits bei "Echoes of the Broadway Everglades..." beginnt, nicht etwa erst nach "needles and pins". Auf der CD wurde dieser Track (wie so oft der Fall) falsch markiert.

[Herma]

The lamb 8
windshield 8
Broadway Melody 9
Cuckoo Cocoon 7
in the cage 10
grand parade 9
back in nyc 5
hairless heart 5
Counting out Time 9 (allerdings bin ich da jetzt durch die Platinumversion "vorbelastet")
Carpet Crawlers 10
Chamber 9

Lilywhite Lilith 8
Waiting Room 6
anyway 8
Supernatural 4
Lamia 5
Silent Sorrow 8
Slipperman 9
Ravine 9
Light dies down 9
Scree 10
rapids 9
it 8


7,91... also 8

[Squonk 8691]

the lamb: 10P.
fly on a windshield: 9P.
melody: 9P. (wie "fly")
cockoo cocoon: 8P.
in the cage: 10P.
parade: 7P.
back in n.y.c.: 9P.
hairless heart: 9P.
counting out time: 8P.
carpet crawlers: 10P.
chamber of 32 doors: 9P.

lilywhite lilith: 9P.
the waiting room: 8P.
anyway: 9P.
anaesthetist: 7P.
the lamia: 8P.
silent sorrow: 8P.
slippermen: 9P.
ravine: 7P.
the light lies down on broadway: 7P.
riding the scree: 9P.
in the rapids: 7P.
it: 10P.

=8,52

Im Schnitt 9 Punkte!

Endlich ma wieder mehr als 8 Punkte! Gefühlte 100 Punkte!

[intairnet]

1.The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway --- 9
2.Fly On A Windshield --- 9
3.Broadway Melody Of 1974 --- 8
4.Cuckoo Cocoon --- 9
5.In The Cage --- 9
6.The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging --- 7
7.Back In N.Y.C. --- 7
8.Hairless Heart --- 8
9.Counting Out Time --- 9
10.Carpet Crawlers --- 10
11.The Chamber Of 32 Doors --- 10
12.Lilywhite Lilith --- 9
13.The Waiting Room --- 9
14.Anyway --- 8
15.Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist --- 8
16.The Lamia --- 8
17.Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats --- 9
18.The Colony Of Slippermen --- 9
19.Ravine --- 8
20.The Light Dies Down On Broadway --- 8
21.Riding The Scree --- 9
22.In The Rapids --- 9
23.It --- 8

199:23 macht 8,65 --> 9

Hab nen gespaltenes Verhältnis zu der Scheibe (den Scheiben)...

...aber ist im Grunde doch zu genial.

Nick

[Optimist]

Durch die Bank weg eine glatte 10.. Diese Scheibe ist einfach genial...